It looks like the pond has spit something out in return for your...monetary offering. So, it seems like you have good reason to be thankful. Probably. Here is the loot:

1. 83. Lavender soap. Smells good! Perfect for wanting to walk out smelling like a plant.
2. 36. Bamboo staff. Don't eat this unless you're a panda.
3. 248. Naomi's Photo. It's a photo of Naomi and Raye Penber. D'aww.
4. 51. Bow-tie. Put it on and feel very fancy!
5. 134. 25 gold coins. Congrats, you received 25 gold coins! Too bad they can't be used to get more items.
6. 106. Star sticker. A golden sticker that says "you tried".
7. 88. Friendship bracelet. A bracelet that has the words 'friends forever' etched into them. Give it to your best buddy!