It looks like the pond has spit something out in return for your...monetary offering. So, it seems like you have good reason to be thankful. Probably. Here is the loot:

1. 250. Jansen's staff. Could've been useful at one point magic-wise, but now very usable to beat people up with a few good aimed hits.
2. 17. Good luck charm. It's a useless piece of paper with 'good luck charm' written on it.